Fineman, 37, shared the divisive tale during a video for Vanity Fair's Game Show series, during which she and her SNL castmates tested how well they know each other.
Chloe Fineman horrified her Saturday Night Live castmates and fans after revealing the 'disturbing' reason she was fired from a job as a teenager.
Fineman, 37, shared the divisive tale during a video for Vanity Fair's Game Show series, during which she and her SNL castmates tested how well they know each other.
Fineman went first, asking her costars Mikey Day, James Austin Johnson, Ashley Padilla, Sarah Sherman and Jane Wickline: 'What job was I fired and later rehired by? Bonus: Why was I fired?'
Her castmates immediately jumped in with their answers, jokingly guessing why she was fired.
'Definitely racially insensitive comments,' Day joked.
'How old were you?' Ashley Padilla asked, with Fineman saying she was 16.
Other cast members guessed that she was fired from a restaurant or retail job, with the comedian then revealing she was fired from her job as a camp counselor.
While Day jokingly guessed she was fired for 'hitting on the campers,' the cast appeared to be more taken aback by the actual answer.
Chloe Fineman horrified her Saturday Night Live castmates and fans after revealing the 'disturbing' reason she was fired from a job as a teenager
But Fineman revealed that she had 'pantsed a boy,' much to the shock of her co-workers.
Padilla exclaimed, 'Oh, honey! I think you're on a list somewhere!'
Fineman doubled down, saying he 'wasn't wearing underpants,' but tried to defend herself by saying: 'It was Berkeley!'
Her confused castmates continued, with Johnson asking, 'What is happening?' and Day then adding, 'how old was the child?'
'He was like six,' Fineman replied, with Padilla gasping and covering her mouth.
Fineman insisted it was a 'different time' as she tried to defend herself.
'Like, he would be like, "Hey, can I have a hug?" And I'd go to hug him and then he'd lift my shirt, like a d**k,' she said.
'I was like, "I'm gonna get back at you,"' she recalled. 'And so we were on a hike, and I was like, "Hey, Ollie, go over there. It's a hawk!" And he looked, and then I yanked his pants down. He wasn't wearing underwear.'
Fineman, 37, insisted it was a 'different time' as she tried to defend herself, with unimpressed fans calling for her to be fired
Join the discussion
Should celebrities be held accountable for inappropriate actions from their past, no matter their age?
'His little ding-a-ling was out,' the comedian added. 'And then these two twins were like, "Ollie, I didn't know you didn't wear underwear!" And then I was fired.'
Fineman quickly moved on to the next question after her shocked co-stars struggled to respond.
But horrified fans took to social media to share their thoughts - many declaring the comedian should be fired from the show and pointing out how visibly uncomfortable the other stars were by the story.
'Ashley in particular was deeply DEEEEEPLY disturbed by it... as she should,' said one.
'I mean... what made her believe sharing that would be smart?' said another.
'Can she just be fired. I'm so tired of Chloe Fineman,' one SNL fan wrote.
'It's finally time for Chloe Fineman to leave the cast. I've prayed for times like this,' said someone else.
'SNL please fire Chloe Fineman,' begged another.
Others appeared to defend Fineman, writing: 'That thing I said about if "Chloe Fineman has a number one fan, it's me" is coming true.'
The Daily Mail reached out to Fineman's representative.
Earlier in the year, the comedian shared another divisive tidbit of her life after uploading a carousel of photos showing her 'botched' cosmetic procedures.
Fineman gave her followers a glimpse into the times she has been left with a battered and bruised face due to a multitude of cosmetic treatments.
Speaking in a voiceover, Fineman said: 'Every year, hundreds of women will say they're going on a trip or visiting family in Connecticut.
'But really, they'll be going ham at a med spa doing crazy s*** like laser stuff, salmon j*** Sculptra plaster or whatever the hell this was.'
She continued: 'These women will hide themselves away in caves like bears while taking hundreds of selfies like this they'll send to friends and family who will lie and say, "It's not that bad."
'This year, I pledge to stop the cycle.'
Ending the clip, Fineman then added: 'Just kidding, I'm going Friday.'
Captioning the upload, she asked: 'Can we normalize having a "Botched" iPhone photo album?'
Fineman's candid post left many of her celebrity pals amused, with Lindsay Lohan, Lisa Rinna and Spencer Pratt all responding with crying laughing emojis.
Others, however, voiced their upset as they implored others to reconsider seeking cosmetic work.