4 min read

A Democratic state lawmaker said Tuesday that Gov. Janet Mills blocked the Maine Department of Transportation from hiring her because she endorsed independent Rick Bennett in the gubernatorial race.

In response to the claims from Rep. Lydia Crafts, a spokesperson for the governor said in a brief written statement that Mills believes such hiring decisions should be made by the next governor after she leaves the Blaine House in January.

Nonetheless, Crafts’ remarks added a bit of drama to a gubernatorial race that has otherwise felt sleepy due to Democrat Hannah Pingree leading Bennett and Republican Bobby Charles by double digits in public polling.

Crafts, a Newcastle Democrat who is not seeking reelection this year after serving three terms in the Maine House of Representatives, told reporters during a Tuesday morning media gaggle in Augusta that Department of Transportation officials approached her earlier this year to tell her to consider applying for a government affairs-related position after she shared her plans to not run for office again. Crafts, who works as a mental health therapist, had co-chaired the Legislature’s Transportation Committee.

Crafts, 43, said she applied for the job after it was posted and made it through two rounds of interviews alongside other candidates. Crafts said Maine DOT Commissioner Dale Doughty and his department told her in late August that they viewed her as the most qualified candidate.

But Crafts said Doughty and the department informed her that Mills had blocked her hire. Crafts told the Portland Press Herald that Doughty said he had tried multiple times to receive approval to hire her but that “he couldn’t do anything else.”

Crafts claimed Mills blocked the hiring because of Crafts’ decision earlier this year to endorse Bennett, a former Republican state senator from Oxford, in the gubernatorial race against Pingree, a former Maine House speaker from North Haven, and Charles, a Leeds lawyer and former assistant U.S. secretary of state. Mills is termed out of office and has endorsed Pingree, who led Mills’ policy office and is the daughter of U.S. Rep. Chellie Pingree, D-1st District.

“I believe I was being punished for exercising my political independence,” Crafts said Tuesday. “I spoke up for my values, stood for what I believe in and was swiftly punished for stepping out of line.”

Later Tuesday afternoon, Crafts also shared a recording of an in-person conversation she had with Doughty on Sept. 2 in which the commissioner told her how “we’ve been asked to hold off” on filling the position “and to reevaluate in January.”

Crafts eventually mentioned Bennett and told Doughty that she “can only assume it has something to do with my political positions.”

“I’m not going to argue. I can’t tell you, but I’m not going to argue with you about that,” Doughty replied.

Anna Parker, Mills’ deputy press secretary, said in a written statement Tuesday that Mills “believes it is appropriate and right to leave staffing decisions, like for the position at Maine DOT, to the judgment of the next governor — regardless of who they are — so that that person may build out a government they believe is best reflective of the will of Maine people.”

The statement did not directly respond to Crafts’ claims of political retaliation. Crafts responded to Parker’s statement by arguing that the governor’s office “did not wait” to hire a new director of the Office of New Americans this summer and that it waited only when the applicant “was someone who endorsed the wrong candidate.”

Doughty and a Department of Transportation spokesperson did not comment Tuesday on the claims from Crafts, who also said in an interview that “three or four prominent Mainers” she refused to name have refrained from publicly supporting Bennett’s campaign because they fear retaliation.

Crafts said she endorsed Bennett due to his political independence and her feeling “disheartened” by how her party’s lawmakers and Mills had started passing majority budgets without Republican support while controlling the Legislature.

Bennett echoed Crafts’ claims Tuesday, saying she was blocked from the Department of Transportation job “because she endorsed me” and that “Maine deserves better.”

“That’s not politics,” Bennett said. “That’s punishment.”

Bennett has trailed Pingree and Charles handily in public polling on the gubernatorial race and remains stuck in the single digits. Last week, a New York Times/Portland Press Herald/Siena poll showed Pingree continuing to lead with 48% support, with Charles at 36% and Bennett at 8%.

Editor’s note: This story was updated Sept. 29 to add material from a recording of a conversation Crafts had with Doughty.