A Toronto judge found that a Nunavut legal service “breached its duty of fairness” when it denied an Iqaluit lawyer re-admission to its panel of criminal lawyers.

In his Aug. 6 decision, Justice Paul Rouleau said the Legal Services Board of Nunavut should reconsider reinstating Alison Crowe to its legal aid panel, the board’s private practice lawyers who provide services to legal aid clients.

“The appropriate disposition is simply to remit the matter to the [board] for reconsideration,” he wrote.

In January, Crowe applied for a judge to order the board to add her to the panel, of which she was a member from around 2012 to October 2024, when she resigned and became a justice of the peace.

In June 2025 applied to rejoin the Legal Aid panel but was denied admittance. In court documents, Crowe said legal aid files had accounted for at least four-fifths of her annual income.

In his letter to inform Crowe of the board’s decision, co-chairperson Tim Zehr said that “a number of concerns were raised, including your interpersonal skills, your ability to work with Inuk staff and some questionable interactions with staff lawyers and judges.”

In January, she asked a judge to order the legal services board to reinstate her.

For that judicial review, the board had to file evidence for the basis of its decision.

For her part, Crowe had to “explain why [the board’s concerns] are either unfounded or do not provide a basis for rejecting her reinstatement application.”

Rouleau stopped short of reinstating her, partially because there was “no allegation of bad faith by the [legal services board].”

“I trust that, now informed of the applicant’s response to its concerns, the [board] will exercise its discretion fairly and appropriately,” he wrote.

Nunatsiaq News reached out to Stephen Bird, who represented the board in January, but he did not respond before press time.

Crowe, when asked for comment, said in an email that “as the matter is still pending, I am limited in what I can say. The decision and pleadings are all public documents and speak for themselves.”