Party discipline, representation, and the condorcet jury theorem

Дата публикации: 08-07-2026 00:00:00

How does district magnitude affect the quality of political representation? The Condorcet Jury Theorem (CJT) predicts that majority decisions improve with group size when members vote independently and are more likely than not to be correct. We test whether this aggregation mechanism applies to political decisions by examining whether larger legislative delegations better reflect constituent preferences. Nominal district magnitude often overstates the number of independent decision-makers because of party discipline. We therefore introduce effective district magnitude as a measure that more accurately captures the number of independently voting politicians within a constituency. Using 263 Swiss referenda (1992–2024) matched to parliamentary decisions, we find that the probability that a majority of a district’s delegation aligns with the preferences of its constituents increases with (effective) district magnitude, consistent with the CJT. The CJT aggregation mechanism closely predicts delegation-constituency congruence only for effective, not nominal, district magnitude. Our results provide empirical evidence that the CJT applies to representative democracies. They also show how party discipline limits the advantages of larger districts.

Схожие новости

#	Наименование новости	Тональность	Информативность	Дата публикации
1	The efficiency paradox of majoritarian democracy	0	6.56	17-08-2026
2	Money talks, moderation walks: the centripetal impact of campaign contributions in the U.S. house	0	9.78	19-08-2026
3	The long decline of trust in democratic institutions	0	6.06	28-07-2026
4	A rationale for political disengagement	0	6.22	19-08-2026
5	Proportional representation primer	0	7.88	30-07-2026
6	Democracia direta aproxima política dos eleitores na Suíça	0	7.34	22-07-2026
7	A characterization of Black’s voting rule	0	5.6	30-07-2026
8	Ranked choice voting with different elimination procedures	0	5.02	10-07-2026
9	“Redistricting Without Tradeoffs”	0	5	07-07-2026

Классификация: . Схожих патентов: 0. Схожих новостей: 9. Тональность: 0. Информативность: 5.9. Источник: rd.springer.com.